Capping IT Off

Capping IT Off

Opinions expressed on this blog reflect the writer’s views and not the position of the Capgemini Group

Buying IT services needs a mature even handed approach

Category : Governance

Current procurement practices are doing a disservice both to the organisations they represent and the suppliers they engage with.

There.  I’ve said it.
But I think it is a widely held view.  The way outsourcing contracts are negotiated almost guarantees a sub-optimal outcome.  Requirements are traded on a tit-for-tat basis that passes for negotiation. In reality what is happening is that issues are being hidden or side-stepped.  They’re still issues though and one day they will cause both sides a problem.
I’m seeing this at the moment in a service integration contract.  The supplier’s proposal called for novel commercial constructs that were designed to foster collaboration amongst an eco-system of the client’s other service providers.  The client had sought this in their Request For Proposal.  Yet the client’s procurement organisation rejected them, intent on retaining their traditional firm grip over suppliers.  This approach can be characterised as “when they perform well we beat them less hard”.

Two years later and the collaboration that is necessary for the desired end-to-end services is lacking.  All of the suppliers, including the service integrator, believe they are doing what they signed up for but the client is dissatisfied.  Tellingly the client has said “You might be meeting your contractual obligations but you are not meeting my expectations”.  Well, sorry but you didn’t contract for unstated expectation fulfillment. 

Successful service integration requires that all parties behave in a rational and adult way from the outset.  It is difficult to address all of the issue that appear during negotiation but it’s better to take the pain then than to deal with it later.  This requires some real rather than notional compromise on behalf of one or more parties; but it will support a more stable and productive relationship during the term of the service. 

About the author

David Griffiths
David Griffiths
David has over 30 years experience in the IT services industry with a record of success in consulting, business unit management and business development roles. He combines a broad understanding of infrastructure and applications technologies with a deep recognition of the need for solutions to be tightly aligned with business issues. David is responsible for the development and communication of Capgemini's Service Integration solution; this combines David’s deep knowledge of outsourcing with his understanding of how organizations behave.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *.