In our previous blog of the series, we discussed how the manufacturing industry in China is overcoming the barriers to restart production post the lock down and why the long term outlook is towards building more resilient supply chains. In this blog article we look at the ways quick service restaurants are accelerating expansion in digitalization to adapt to post lock down digital trends to sustain customer loyalty.
For QSR chains in China, the difficulties started at the end of January with the implementation of city lock downs. In the ensuing months, similar lock downs have been experienced across the world. Some restaurants have closed altogether, while others have remained open, but purely to take orders for pick-up or home delivery.
As China’s lock down has lifted, what insights can the country’s quick service restaurants (QSR) chains offer to global counterparts on the path to recovery?
Taken by surprise at the end of January, QSR chains in China had only a few days to reinvent their business model in order to survive. For example:
- Yum China, which owns the KFC chain among others, had to shut down 35% of its restaurants in February. Receiving lower traffic, the stores that remained open lost over 40% of their sales, which resulted in a total drop of sales in excess of 60%.
- Starbucks shut down over 50% of its stores in February and saw a 78% total drop in sales compared to the same period last year. The drop of sales peaked at 90% in mid-February.
- Dicos (a local QSR with more than 2,600 outlets) closed over 60% of the stores during the outbreak.
Restaurants that remained open were forced to adapt their operations in line with a government mandate to limit their opening hours according to local policy, for example, from 10am to 4pm. They were also forced to provide touchless takeaway and delivery services, as all dine-in spaces were closed.
Managing customer experiences during the lockdown
Customers’ new expectations
Customers in China were quick to adapt their consumption habits during the lockdown by switching to mobile ordering and home delivery. For Starbucks, 80%2 of orders were made on a smart phone during the lockdown, of which 30% were delivered to the customer, and 50% collected as a takeaway. For KFC, 84% of orders were from digital channels, including smart phone, deliver platforms, and kiosk with mobile payment, in first quarter of 2020, an increase of 29% compared to same period last year.
Although no longer eating in restaurant premises, customers ordering takeaway and delivery services still had high expectations of food hygiene and safety. This benefited leading global chains like KFC, recognized in China for their high standards of operating procedures and hygiene protocols.
Hygiene and safety first
Restaurants placed hygiene and safety at the center of their service protocols, even in the absence of customers:
- All restaurant staff were required to wear masks, sanitize their hands, and have their body temperature checked frequently.
- Delivery service staff had their body temperature measured when entering the restaurants and washed their hands before and after each delivery.
- Pick-up and delivery processes were designed to avoid human contact. Restaurants installed external pick-up counters to prevent delivery operators from entering the premises, and delivery racks were installed outside most apartment buildings and communities to hand-over the meal to the end-customer without contact.
Digital has been a core component of Quick Service Restaurants in China since 2015. Indeed, KFC and Dicos developed their own apps, partnering with large food delivery platforms, such as Eleme and Meituan, to secure delivery. They also developed their own WeChat mini programs to generate traffic.
However, the lockdown accelerated adoption of these existing digital models as QSRs ramped up digital commerce with new services and functionality. This strengthened their take-away capacity beyond the touchless services described above. For example:
- Mini programs and apps encouraged consumers to pre-order meals as early as possible to avoid waiting too long.
- Mobile platforms enabled customers not just to order and pay for their food, but to track delivery as well.
- New digital loyalty programs were used to convert consumers into loyal customers.
Coming out of the crisis
As China gradually came out of the lockdown towards the end of March, people started to return to work and restaurants began reopening for dining.
- At Yum China, 95%1 of the stores were open and still 10%-20% of the stores only offered takeaway and deliver service by the end of March. Sales are reported 24% lower as compared to the same period last year. Among their brands, KFC has performed better with 15% sales slump. Even with the lockdown now over, customers still show a preference for takeaways, with delivery sales as a percentage of company sales approximately doubling during this period.
- At Starbucks, 95% of its stores were open by mid-April including two new stores. Order preference began to slowly shift from takeaway back to dine-in, when available. However, a remnant effect of the crisis can be observed in the tripling of the share of online orders: They represented 27% of the total by the end of March 2020, as compared to an average of 10% in June 2019. Starbucks’ mobile orders are enabled via a variety of channels, including apps, mini programs and food delivery platforms.
- At Dicos, 90% of its stores were back to operation by mid-March and delivery represented over 40% of the orders. They expected this delivery order volume to drop when dining-in service reopened.
For restaurant chains in China, the pandemic accelerated customers’ education and broadened adoption of digital channels.
Originally, mini programs and apps were mostly used by young customers. During the crisis period, more middle-aged and senior people joined online platforms. Consumers adopted digital habits that they would not have learned otherwise, and many purchase behaviors have remained after the pandemic.
New utilizations of digital ordering are now becoming a standard. Before the lockdown, most restaurant chains had developed a self-ordering functionality designed to make service more efficient, whereby:
- Each table was marked with a unique QR code
- Customers scanned the QR code in the app and placed their order online (from meal selection to payment)
- The order then went directly to the kitchen without requiring a waiter.
This practice is now not only seen as more efficient, but also more secure because it limits the interaction with the restaurant staff. It has become so widely adopted that, in some chains, waiters are surprised when customers ask for a (paper) menu and expect them to take their order.
Driving traffic back to store
As they strengthened their digital presence, restaurant chains in China also kept in mind that, as well as selling food, they provided a differentiated in-store experience as part of their revenue model. So, the acceleration of digital commerce also offered them a way to attract customers back to their stores when confinement was over. They promptly engaged in actions to leverage the new digital customers they had acquired during the lockdown, and to activate old loyalty program members to push them to visit the newly reopened restaurants. For example, the valuable data obtained on the new users’ preferences enabled them to directly engage and start targeted marketing operations
As an example, KFC is widely using digital marketing campaigns. On April 14, known as KFC’s Member Day, the company offered 50% off for Fried Chicken basket purchases for members and for takeaway orders. This campaign not only drove traffic from online to offline but was also very efficient in generating a social media buzz.
Like QSRs in China, others around the world might also see an accelerated expansion in digitalization as a result of enforced consumer habit changes during the lockdown. How QSRs rejuvenate their pre-crisis customer engagement and loyalty platforms, while adapting to the post-crisis hyper-digital normal, will define their success in the coming months and years.